Polisorb mp or enterosgel which is better. Polysorb analogs: a list of effective drugs

Once in the human body, they absorb poisonous toxins and are excreted naturally. Thus, by neutralizing toxic substances, they provide tremendous assistance to the liver, in its cleansing activity and put the intestines, blood and stomach in order.

The most popular in the recommendations of doctors and patients are Polysorb and Enterosgel. These drugs have a lot of positive reviews, are dispensed without a prescription and are allowed for independent use. But how do these sorbents differ? And in favor of which one to choose if their price varies so much?

Polysorb

Polisorb, domestic enterosorbent, registered. It is a very soft powder, soluble in water, with tiny dust-like granules - silica (silicon dioxide). When it enters the water, it dissolves well, forming a "suspension", almost no sediment. Fairly easy to drink. It has great absorption capacity.

It acts instantly as soon as it enters the body. Absorbing pathogenic substances, allergens, toxins or infections, 1 gram of the drug can cleanse the entire surface of the intestines, an adult - 200 m², and the sorption capacity of Polysorb is 300 m². It is not absorbed in the intestines and blood, it is excreted unchanged. The entire mechanism of action occurs on the surface of the nanoparticles, and not in the pores, as in many others.

Dosing regimen and features of administration

Calculate 1 g of sorbent (1 tsp, with a "slide") per 10 kg of human body weight. Diluted with 1/2 or 1/4 cup of water to obtain a suspension. Up to 10 kg - 0.5-1.5 tsp per day for 30-50 ml of water. Prepared immediately before taking, drunk one hour before meals.

Due to the non-porous surface, the drug has a high absorption rate, 2-3 minutes. The sorbent has no age restrictions, it can be used by pregnant and lactating mothers, as well as newborn children.

Indications for use

This is a universal helper in your first aid kit.

With long-term treatment, it is necessary to consult a doctor, since Polysorb does not work so selectively, regarding harmful and beneficial substances, when used for more than two weeks, the drug disrupts the intestinal microflora and can cause a lack of vitamins.

Contraindications

It is forbidden to use Polysorb:

1. With intestinal atony.
2. Peptic ulcer.
3. Gastrointestinal bleeding.
4. The drug is not prescribed for hypersensitivity to silicon dioxide.

Side effects

Increased constipation, allergic reactions. But, all these problems can be avoided by using a large amount of liquid (up to 3 liters per day) or by using fermented milk products.

Price and storage conditions

An important plus of this sorbent, its price depends on the packaging, from 30 to 300 rubles. Does not react to temperature changes, but it is recommended to store Polysorb at room temperature, not higher than 25°C.

Enterosgel, produced in Russia, complies with GOST and all the rules of the GMP standard. Effective, detoxifying, new generation enterosorbent.

It is a paste or gel, sweetish in taste and ready for use, but it is required to drink boiled water, room temperature or suspension preparation.

Produced now, in a new, convenient packaging-tube. Active ingredient, porous structure of a silicon compound ( methylsilicic acid). The sorption capacity is exactly half that of Polysorb, therefore, it requires more sorbent intake.

Dosing regimen

• Adults are prescribed 15g (1-1.5 tablespoons) - up to 3 times a day.
• Children under 5 years old - (0.5 tablespoons) up to 3 times a day.
• from 5 to 15 years old - 1 tbsp. 3 times a day.

The specific dosage depends on the indications for use. Within 12 hours, it effectively absorbs medium molecular toxic substances from the intestines, blood, and removes them with feces. Does not reduce the absorption of vitamins, trace elements and does not dehydrate the body.

Indications for use

In general, when applied, it improves the functioning of the liver, kidneys, activates intestinal motility, and absolutely does not interfere with the microflora. Against the background of possible aggressive external factors (vomiting, heartburn), due to the enveloping action, it has a beneficial effect on the gastrointestinal tract, has an anti-inflammatory and regenerating property.

• Able to remove toxins.
• Microorganisms (opportunistic and pathogenic).
• Treat acute intestinal infections:
• Infectious nature (toxic infections, salmonellosis, dysentery).
• Non-infectious - dysbacteriosis.
• Remove allergies.
• It is used in the complex treatment for purulent-septic diseases.
• in the treatment of viral hepatitis.
• Absorbs excess bilirubin
• It is used as a prophylactic agent of intoxication for workers at hazardous enterprises.
• Reduces the manifestations of toxicosis in pregnant women

Available in pharmacies without a prescription, with long-term treatment, it is recommended to consult a doctor.

Contraindications

The reason for canceling Entersogel may be:

• Peptic ulcer of the stomach and duodenum (in the acute phase).
• Bleeding from the gastrointestinal tract.
• Atony of the intestine.
• Acute intestinal obstruction.
• Individual intolerance to the drug

Side effects

Sometimes, there is nausea, flatulence, or constipation (in people prone to them).

Price and storage conditions

Enterosgel is stored at room temperature, not lower than 15°C and not higher than 25°C. Shelf life 3 years. The drug should be protected from drying and freezing.

What's better? When and what should be used?

Since these sorbents have a similar composition, it can be observed that they are used to get rid of the same problems:

• For instant impact.
• For preventive purposes.
• With a therapeutic effect, against the background of the main treatment.

Their influence extends simultaneously to the entire body.

Emergency use or long-term treatment

By the speed of impact, Polysorb is 3 times higher than adsorption. In comparison with Enetrosgel, it will cleanse the body much faster. But such a high absorbing effect may not always be beneficial, since vitamins and microelements are excreted along with harmful substances. Therefore, with long-term use, if the choice stops at this enterosorbent, the doctor should recommend the use of additional vitamins and "live" bacteria in the form of fermented milk products. People who are prone to constipation need to be careful about course treatment and seek advice from a doctor.

With long-term use, Enterosgel, due to its composition and gel-like state, cleanses gently, carefully and selectively. It not only leaves the necessary useful elements, but also has a beneficial effect on some organs and systems in general. If you follow the annotation, and do not exceed the duration of the intake, the intestinal microflora is not affected, and does not require the use of bifidobacteria.

You can use these drugs once and independently. For course therapy, a doctor's recommendation and diagnosis is always needed. We may not know the existing contraindications, these may be diseases of the gastrointestinal tract, intestinal atony, peptic ulcer, kidney and liver failure, intolerance to the composition.

Price and nuances of choice

By price, Enterosgel, almost 2 times more expensive than Polysorb. Many argue that the gel consistency is very unpleasant and hard to drink, to which doctors recommend diluting Enteresgel in water as well as Polysorb. It, in turn, leaves a small residue, which can also make it difficult to swallow. It is much more convenient to take Enterosgel with you, on the road or on vacation, because of the packaging and the possibility of quick use, because. we already know that it is enough to drink it with water, in an emergency.

Even experts cannot definitively answer the question “Which is better?”. The intake and choice of an enterosorbent depends on the task assigned to it, the duration of the prescribed treatment, contraindications (available or not), your body, financial capabilities and taste preferences.

With the modern pace of life, with a disturbed diet, rest and work regime, the accumulation of toxic substances often occurs. Improper functioning of the immune system, digestive tract, impaired kidney function and alcohol dependence require proper treatment. What do these diseases have in common? The presence of exotoxins and endotoxins in the body. One of the effective ways to remove dangerous foreign substances is the use of enterosorbents.

• By pharmacological affiliation, it belongs to enterosorbing agents of non-natural origin.
• Active ingredient - silicon dioxide colloidal.
• Available as a white powder, which is packaged in sealed bags of 1/2/3/6/10/12 grams each. To use, open the package and dissolve the contents in warm water. Water is filled to half or one-fourth of a glass. The dose of the necessary substance is calculated depending on the cause of the disease, the age and weight of the patient.
• The mechanism of action is similar to the Filtrum enterosorbent. In the intestinal lumen, the active substrate binds endogenous, exogenous toxins and allergens.
• Contraindications - peptic ulcer of the duodenum and stomach in the acute stage, intestinal bleeding, individual intolerance to the components of the drug.

Drug Similarities

Medicines are analogues according to the mechanism of action. After entering the small intestine, the substances, without entering into a chemical reaction with the components of the food bolus, remove toxins as part of the feces.

Similar contraindications for drugs. The group of enterosorbents is not used in the stage of exacerbation of peptic ulcer and with individual intolerance to individual components.

The effectiveness of both substances is thousands of times higher than that of activated carbon. This fact will provide a pronounced and rapid clinical effect.

"Filtrum" and "Polysorb" in addition to toxic poisoning are used to alleviate the symptoms of food and drug allergies. This is achieved by binding allergens.

Both drugs are taken one hour before meals 3 times a day.

Also, with prolonged use, drugs can lead to poor absorption of nutrients and vitamins. This should be taken into account when taking funds during flowering as a weakening of the manifestations of allergies.

Side effects of enterosorbents rarely cause. Possible - constipation and intolerance to the components of the drug.

Medicines are suitable for children from infancy. Which is important, since children have an imperfect digestive system and an excessive craving for knowing the world through their mouths.

Differences

1. Medicines are used various active ingredients. "Filtrum" includes a natural component of lignin and lactulose, the combination of which contributes to rapid excretion due to increased peristalsis. In "Polysorb" there is silicon dioxide obtained artificially.
2. "Polysorb" is produced in a more voluminous and economical package in the form of a powder. "Filtrum" uses tablets for swallowing as a form of release, which in some situations is inconvenient. For example, in the case of children. In this case, it is necessary to grind the tablet to prevent accidental inhalation.
3. The use of "Polysorb" can be used as masks by patients with problem skin. Other enterosorbents are not used in this way.
4. "Polysorb" has an antiseptic effect, due to which it can be used externally for various skin lesions.

Drug of choice

If symptoms of poisoning occur: nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, weakness and headaches in an adult, both drugs can be used. Both pharmacological agents are effective in this case. The choice will be based on material possibilities. "Filtrum" is a more budgetary analogue than "Polysorb".

If poisoning occurs in children, it is more expedient to use the drug in the form of a powder, to facilitate administration. The younger the child, the more he needs a soluble medicine.

"Polysorb" and "Filtrum" are allowed for children of any age, even for the smallest.

Both drugs are also suitable for relieving allergy symptoms, and the choice will depend on financial capabilities and personal preferences. "Filtrum" will be more effective when it is necessary to quickly remove the allergen. Due to the fact that lactulose, which is part of the drug, helps to increase peristalsis and increase excretion with feces.

Polysorb or Enterosgel sorbents - which is better for allergies, many doctors still argue. Enterosorbents in traditional medicine are used everywhere - for poisoning, allergic manifestations, skin diseases, functional disorders of the gastrointestinal tract and organs of the urinary system.

To date, there are several popular adsorbents that differ in their properties, action and the presence of side reactions. Which one is more effective and how do the drugs differ?

Polysorb or Enterosgel. What is more convenient to use

Both sorbents have a different release form:

• Enterosgel is available in the form of a paste and a gel-like suspension. Both types of the drug are ready for use, if desired, the gel is diluted with water or juice. The adsorbent has no taste and smell and is easy to use.
• Polysorb has a powdery structure that requires dilution before taking the right amount of liquid. This is not always convenient if you need to take the remedy outside the home.

Polysorb or Enterosgel. Allergy drug safety

Polysorb has a high sorption activity, which is not always good. Enterosgel differs from all sorbents, including those based on highly dispersed silica, by its selective action.

The enterosorbent acts due to organic silicon, which promotes the binding of harmful medium molecular weight compounds (toxins, allergens, metabolites), while not affecting beneficial substances.

Polysorb is a sorbent that is active with respect to proteins. In practice, it is often prescribed to people with burns in order to cleanse the blood of toxic substances of a protein nature.

However, in all other cases, it is recommended to take a sorbent with selective properties - Enterosgel, which will preserve the integrity of useful substances, including proteins, preventing the appearance of edema, anemia, muscle weakness, and a decrease in the protective functions of the body.

Preservation of microflora: what is more effective. Video

Given the different selectivity of sorbents, one should carefully choose a drug for long-term use.

• Polysorb is a non-selective enterosorbent, therefore, after its use, the development of dysbacteriosis is not excluded.
• Enterosgel acts more delicately, being localized exclusively in the intestines. It cleanses the body of toxins, pathogens, poisons, keeping the natural intestinal microflora normal.

Enterosgel, unlike Polysorb, has no contraindications in the form of erosive and ulcerative lesions of the mucous membranes of internal organs.

If it is necessary to take enterosorbents, people do not know what to choose - Polysorb or Enterosgel. The drugs have a single purpose - the removal of toxins and toxins from the body, but the form of release is different for them.

Characteristics of Polysorb

Polysorb is a modern preparation with a high sorption capacity - 300 mg/g. Its strengths are:

• a wide range of applications (for allergies, alcohol intoxication, poisoning, diarrhea, toxicosis of pregnant women);
• speed (the drug is active 2-4 minutes after ingestion);
• safety (the drug is allowed during pregnancy, lactation and children from birth);
• the ability to remove toxins of various sizes and origins;
• selective effect - the drug absorbs only harmful substances, leaving beneficial microorganisms that inhabit the intestinal tract (if the course of treatment does not exceed 2 weeks).

The active substance of Polysorb is colloidal silicon dioxide - a colorless crystalline rock of high hardness and strength. Silica does not react with water, it is resistant to acid, due to which the sorbent is excreted from the body unchanged.

The principle of operation of the sorbent is based on the absorption (adsorption) of harmful substances and waste products of bacteria by chemical action with them.

Polysorb MP (the abbreviation indicates the scope of the drug - medical oral) goes on sale in the form of a white powder for the preparation of a suspension in sachets of 3 g and in jars of 12, 25, 35 and 50 g.

Characteristics of enterosgel

Enterosgel is a modern sorbent based on the same silica, but in a different form - methylsilicic acid hydrogel. The drug is inert, that is, it does not enter into metabolic and chemical processes in the body, it is excreted unchanged. Enterosgel envelops the mucous membranes of the digestive tract, protecting them from damage and increasing local immunity, adsorbs medium-sized toxin molecules and removes them naturally. The sorption capacity of the drug is 105-150 mg/g

The sorbent is effectively used for allergic reactions, intoxications of various origins and severity (toxicosis of pregnant women, poisoning with alcohol, narcotic substances, heavy metals, radiation damage), viral diseases (hepatitis A and B), dysbacteriosis and other diseases of the digestive tract.

Enterosgel is safe for young children from birth, pregnant and lactating women.

It is sold in the form of a paste in portion bags of 15 g and in jars of 135, 270, 405 g.

What is the difference

The following parameters are used to compare sorbents:

• sorption capacity (the amount of toxins excreted by the drug per unit of its mass);
• the ability to remove from the body substances that differ in size, mass, structure, origin;
• the area of ​​active sorption, that is, the external area of ​​the molecule;
• general toxicity to the body;
• the degree of injury to the mucous membranes of the gastrointestinal tract;
• biological compatibility of the drug with human cells and tissues.

Polysorb and Enterosgel belong to the same group of sorbents - containing silicon dioxide, so both drugs are safe, non-toxic, non-traumatic. All sorbents with silica more effectively remove toxic substances from the body than their counterparts - activated and white carbon, preparations based on lingin (for example, lactofiltrum), smectites. Their sorption capacity is 5-10 mg / g, 18 and 100, respectively. However, Polysorb and Enterosgel are not the same, since there are a number of differences, in addition to sorption capacity, appearance and structure.

Ease of use

Paste Enterosgel is sold ready to use - it is available in portioned sachets-sticks.

Polysorb MP powder must be diluted with water and thoroughly mixed until smooth.

Application safety

Safety is determined by the selectivity of the sorbent, its effect with water and the effect on the work of the gastrointestinal tract.

Selectivity of drugs. Enterosgel removes toxins and slags, leaving vitamins, minerals, trace elements and proteins in the body, which makes it a more gentle preparation. The increased sorption activity of Polysorb to protein compounds does not allow its use in low-calorie diets and intoxications with increased breakdown of protein rocks, and in case of intoxication from burns, the powder will be more effective than the paste.

Water binding is an important parameter in a dehydrated state of the body. Enterosgel needs less water molecules than Polysorb, so it does not affect intestinal motility, does not slow down metabolic processes in it, and when taken for a long time (more than 10 days) does not lead to atony.

Impact on the microflora

Enterosgel affects the intestinal microflora more delicately, therefore it does not harm it.

Non-selective Polysorb inhibits the development and growth of both harmful and beneficial bacteria, so dysbacteriosis may occur.

What is better to take

The choice of sorbent is the prerogative of the attending physician, who takes into account the patient's condition, his age characteristics, the presence of contraindications and possible side effects. Polysorb should not be taken with exacerbations of ulcers and erosion, bleeding in the gastrointestinal tract, suspicion of rupture of the mucous membranes. Enterosgel is allowed under such conditions.

Prevention of dehydration

Dehydration can occur with intoxication of the body during intense weight loss, intestinal infections and exposure to viruses, rotoviruses, and kidney diseases. During treatment and detoxification, they try to prevent excessive loss of fluid, therefore, they use a sorbent with the highest selectivity for water molecules - Enterosgel paste.

Polysorb and Enterosgel in case of poisoning

Polysorb is indicated for acute forms of poisoning, intestinal infections of bacteriological and viral breeds, as well as for the purpose of prevention when changing the usual diet, working with harmful conditions, living or visiting environmentally unfavorable regions.

Enterosgel is recommended for acute poisoning with chemicals and medicines, infectious intoxications, and allergic reactions. The sorbent is used as a prophylactic agent for industrial poisoning.

Polysorb and Enerosgel in case of poisoning

In case of poisoning, Enterosgel or Polysorb MP are taken as antidotes separately from other medicines, since sorbents can reduce the effectiveness of drugs. Wait 2-4 hours between doses.

Polysorb powder is diluted with the required amount of water and carefully stirred until a homogeneous suspension is formed.

Enterosgel is washed down with a large amount of liquid, but for a small child, the paste can also be diluted in a spoonful of water.

How can sorbents harm

With prolonged use (more than 10 days), hypovitaminosis may occur, the intestinal microflora may be disturbed. The first disease is treated by taking vitamin complexes and introducing vegetables and fruits into the diet. Dysbacteriosis is characterized by the occurrence of constipation or diarrhea, flatulence, abdominal pain, nausea, vomiting, heartburn. Probiotics, fresh fermented milk products, foods rich in fiber will help get rid of it.

The opinion of doctors about Polysorb and Enterosgel

There is no consensus among doctors about which drug is better. Polysorb acts faster, so its use is advisable in critical conditions of the body. At the same time, the powdered sorbent has more contraindications and has a non-selective effect, so side effects are possible. Enterosgel is more gentle, so it is more often prescribed for infants, pregnant and lactating women, and the elderly. Due to the selective effect, the paste is devoid of side effects and has no contraindications.

Symptoms of poisoning are familiar to everyone, even children. Every person has experienced this at least once in their life. And more often than not. Such cases require urgent action. And not only because vomiting and diarrhea are extremely unpleasant in themselves. They can lead to a large loss of fluid in the body. And this is very dangerous, especially in children.

Currently, there are excellent means of salvation from this ailment. These are drugs that can absorb substances that cause trouble to our body. Enterodez and enterosgel are the most popular today. Let's figure out what and when is better to take.

Enterodes is an inexpensive first aid drug!

Available in the form of a powder, from which you need to prepare a solution. It turns out almost transparent liquid. This solution should be stored in the refrigerator door and used within three days. It begins to act within half an hour after drinking it.

The remedy is good because it is not absorbed into the blood. It acted in the intestines and was excreted from it. It can be used for intestinal disorders caused by any pathogens, in case of poisoning with poor-quality food, medicines. And also with liver and kidney failure, when the organs cannot cope with the elimination of poisons and they need help.

This drug should not be used only if the person does not tolerate it well. After taking the drug, in rare cases, you may feel sick, there may be vomiting and increased sensitivity to sunlight. Therefore, if treated for several days, it is better to avoid going to the beach and long exposure to the sun.

It is possible to apply to women in a happy period of waiting for a baby, if you weigh the benefits for the mother and the possible risk for the unborn baby. With severe vomiting and frequent diarrhea, not only the expectant mother suffers, but also the baby. So in this case, they will definitely need treatment.

This drug can be used even in small children, starting from one year. To prevent children from being capricious, you can sweeten the healing solution for them or add fruit juice to it.

Average price 110 - 160 rubles. Produced in Russia, it is stored for 2 years.

Enterosgel is an effective sorbent

Produced in the form of a paste in plastic tubes of 225 and 450 grams, as well as in bags of 15 and 45 grams. For kids, you can buy sweet pasta.

It removes not only poisons, but also bacteria, and substances that cause allergies, as well as radioactive particles and alcohol. This drug can absorb excess toxic substances that systems and organs do not have time to cope with on their own, for example, with viral hepatitis, kidney failure. It is also good for severe purulent inflammatory diseases. In this case, enterosgel will not become the basis of treatment, but will help improve the person's condition.

It is recommended to use this medicine periodically for employees of enterprises that have harmful effects. Can be applied every month for 10 days. The advantage is that it does not deprive a person of vitamins and trace elements. Enterosgel simply does not absorb them! It also helps to strengthen the normal and necessary bacteria in the intestines.

Can be used in children older than one year. And women in an "interesting position" are not recommended to use it.

You can not use the drug if:

• Strongly reduced bowel tone.
• The person does not tolerate drugs from the group of sulfonamides.

There may be the following side effects:

• Nausea.
• Constipation.
• Allergy.

Price from 360 to 450 rubles on average across the country. Produced in Russia, shelf life - 3 years.

Enterodez and enterosgel: what do they have in common?

Both are representatives of the same pharmaceutical group - enterosorbents, that is, they are able to effectively absorb poisons. Both can be used for both adults and children over one year old.

Comparison of drugs enterodez and enterosgel

Enterosgel is best used for conditions and diseases that require it. frequent use. These are chronic poisoning of the body by any poisons. It is practically indispensable for workers who daily face occupational hazards. In this case, it is better to use this tool.

Occupational hazards are constant, therefore it is better to use it every month in small courses. The same applies to the treatment of allergies. Here you will need a course of the drug for 2-3 weeks. To alleviate the condition in case of renal or hepatic insufficiency, it is also recommended to use it. It is very important here that the medicine does not remove useful and necessary substances intended for a person.

If a person is simply poisoned by poor-quality food, chemicals, or an intestinal infection occurs, enterodesis can be taken. The course of treatment here will be small, only 3-5 days. In addition, if the price of the medicine matters, then enterodesis will not hit your pocket hard. The drug will also cope well with its task with excessive alcohol consumption. If you went too far with alcohol the day before, then it’s good to have enterodesis in stock.